The studio peak
2000s Rom Coms: 10 Films The Studio Era Got Right
2000s rom coms that hold up: ten studio-era films from Legally Blonde to The Proposal, plus an honest note on the ones that did not age well.
On this shelf
Bridget Jones's Diary 2001
2001
The diary voice gives it a structure most rom coms never bother to build.
Best for A night when you want to laugh at someone else's bad decisions
Legally Blonde 2001
2001
A comedy that is smarter about its lead than it gets credit for, and funny in every scene.
Best for When you need something genuinely cheering
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days 2003
2003
Two people lying to each other for different reasons, which is a better engine than it sounds.
Best for A Friday night with no thinking required
Love Actually 2003
2003
A set of short films of uneven quality, two of which are genuinely great.
Best for December, with a disagreement afterwards
13 Going on 30 2004
2004
The studio film from this decade that has aged best.
Best for A wish-fulfilment evening that does not insult you
The Holiday 2006
2006
A house swap and two actors who know exactly what film they are in.
Best for A cold week in December
Music and Lyrics 2007
2007
A has-been pop star and a plant lady write a song, and the film is better than its premise.
Best for When you want the decade's gentlest comedy
27 Dresses 2008
2008
A wardrobe of bad dresses and a lead who is finally allowed to want something.
Best for When you want the bridesmaid film
Definitely, Maybe 2008
2008
A father tells his daughter three love stories and lets her guess which one is her mother.
Best for A Sunday when you want a puzzle
The Proposal 2009
2009
A work visa premise that only works because both leads commit completely.
Best for When you want two actors carrying a silly plot
The decade everyone dismisses and keeps watching
The two thousands is the period critics decided the rom com was dead, and it is also the period with the highest number of films that people actually rewatch. Both things are true. The studio system made a lot of them quickly, to a formula, with stars who were cast for likability. A few of those films are much better than the formula deserved.
This page is the short version: ten films from the era that hold up, and an honest note on the ones that do not.
What the studio era got right
The two thousands had two things the decade before it lacked: budgets big enough to build a world, and actors who could do comedy and romance in the same scene. That combination produced films that are generous to their audiences — they want you to like the people on screen, and they spend real money making the world look inviting.
It also produced a particular kind of bad film: the one where the obstacle is a work deadline, the misunderstanding could be cleared up with one sentence, and nobody involved seems to want anything. The difference between the two is usually the script, not the budget. Legally Blonde and How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days cost nothing alike, and both work because a real writer thought about the character.
The five worth starting with
Bridget Jones's Diary is the decade's best film, and the reason is structural: the diary gives it a voice most rom coms never bother to find. Love Actually is the one that gets argued about every December, and the argument is the point — it is a set of short films of varying quality, and two of them are genuinely great.
13 Going on 30 is the one that aged best. The premise is a wish, the execution is a lead performance, and it does not lean on the joke of a teenager in an adult body for longer than it can carry.
The Holiday and The Proposal are the two that most people remember fondly and cannot defend. Both are watchable for the same reason: two actors who know exactly what kind of film they are in. That is a real skill, and it is why both of them still get queued up in December.
The ones that did not survive
A lot of the decade's biggest hits are hard to sit through now. The jokes about weight, about women's careers, about the friend who is obviously in love with the lead — those were standard then and are not now. That does not make the films worthless, but it does mean you should not start a first date with one of them without knowing what you are putting on.
Where to go next
If you want the decade that preceded this one, 90s rom coms is where the template was built. If you want the smaller films from the same years that nobody marketed, underrated rom coms is the shelf. And if you want the whole genre in one place, rom com movies covers all four eras.
Frequently asked questions
Which 2000s rom com is actually the best?
Bridget Jones's Diary, because the diary voice gives it a structure the rest of the decade did not have. 13 Going on 30 has aged best of the studio films.
Why do some 2000s rom coms feel dated?
The ones where the obstacle is a work deadline and the misunderstanding could be solved by one honest sentence. If the leads do not want anything real, no budget can fix it.
Are these the films people rewatch at Christmas?
Love Actually and The Holiday are both Christmas films, so both get rewatched in December. They are a set of short stories and a house-swap premise respectively, and both depend on the cast rather than the plot.