Buried by bad timing
Underrated Rom Coms: 10 Films A Bad Release Buried
Underrated rom coms that a bad release date buried: ten films including Man Up and Plus One, with the reason each one deserves a second look.
On this shelf
Man Up 2015
2015
Sold as a broad comedy, actually a two-hander about one honest conversation.
Best for When you want the best film on this page
Sleeping with Other People 2015
2015
Two people who are bad at relationships try being friends instead.
Best for When the perfect people on screen are getting boring
Plus One 2019
2019
Two friends survive a summer of weddings and quietly fall for each other.
Best for Anyone who has been the single friend at a wedding
The Broken Hearts Gallery 2020
2020
A woman starts an art gallery for other people's break-up objects, and it works better than it should.
Best for A night when you want to laugh at the premise
Destination Wedding 2018
2018
Two people who dislike each other at a wedding they both want to leave.
Best for When you want two actors arguing for ninety minutes
Celeste and Jesse Forever 2012
2012
Two people who love each other but should not be married, which is a harder film than the studio version.
Best for After a break-up, when you want the honest version
The Five-Year Engagement 2012
2012
A couple who keep postponing the wedding, with jokes that come from character rather than premise.
Best for When you want a long engagement joke that lands
Long Story Short 2021
2021
A time-jump premise played as a comedy of small embarrassments rather than a moral lesson.
Best for A weeknight when you want something light and odd
What's Your Number? 2011
2011
Funnier than its premise and better cast than its release suggested.
Best for When you want the messy studio version
The Lovebirds 2020
2020
A couple on the verge of breaking up get pulled into a night they did not plan.
Best for When you want something that goes silly for a while
What "underrated" means here
Every list of underrated films is really a list of films that were badly released. A romantic comedy does not disappear because it is bad. It disappears because it opened against something bigger, because the trailer sold the wrong film, because it went straight to streaming with no marketing budget, or because the studio had already stopped caring.
The ten films on this page all survived that. None of them are masterpieces. All of them are better than the reception they got, and most people who like romantic comedies have never heard of half of them.
The three most common ways a rom com gets buried
The first is a bad date. A small film opening the same weekend as a franchise release does not get a second week, and after that it is only findable if someone recommends it by name.
The second is a misleading trailer. Man Up is the clearest case: the marketing sold it as a broad comedy about a misunderstanding, and the film is actually a two-hander about two people having one long honest conversation. People who went expecting the trailer did not come back.
The third is the streaming dump. Since about 2018, a large number of perfectly good romantic comedies have premiered on a platform with no press, no poster campaign and no reviews, and were effectively invisible for their first year.
Where to start
Start with Man Up and Plus One. The first is the best film on the page and the one that most deserves a second life. The second is the most reliable crowd-pleaser: two friends, a summer of weddings, and a plot that does not cheat.
If you want something messier and more interesting, go to Sleeping with Other People and Celeste and Jesse Forever. Both are about people who are bad at relationships and know it, which is a harder film to make than the studio version. And if you want the one that is genuinely strange, Destination Wedding is two actors arguing for ninety minutes in a hotel, and it is much better than that sounds.
Why these lists matter more than the top tens
A top ten tells you what everyone already knows. An underrated list is the only way a film gets rediscovered ten years later, because the mechanism is personal recommendation: someone watches it, likes it, and tells two people. That is how most of the films on this page got the audience they eventually found.
That is also the logic of this whole site. Niche rom coms is the same idea applied to the genre as a whole, and indie rom coms is the same idea applied to the films made outside the studio system.
A caveat
If you watch one of these and do not like it, that is fair. Underrated does not mean universally good, and a film that was badly marketed can still be a film that is not for you. The point of the list is that these are worth a try, not that they are owed your approval.
If you want the films that are agreed on by almost everyone, go to best rom coms. If you want the whole shelf in one place, rom com movies has everything, and feel good rom coms filters for nothing that will ruin the evening.
Frequently asked questions
What makes a rom com underrated?
A film that was badly released: opened against a bigger film, was sold by a misleading trailer, or premiered on a streaming platform with no marketing. Underrated does not mean the film is a masterpiece, only that it is better than the reception it got.
Which underrated rom com should I watch first?
Man Up is the best of them and the one most deserving of a second life. Plus One is the safest bet if you want something a group will enjoy.
How did these films get buried?
Man Up is the clearest example: the trailer sold it as a broad comedy of errors, and the film is actually a long honest conversation between two people. The audience the trailer brought in did not come back.