No studio notes
Indie Rom Coms: 10 Small Films That Beat The Studio Ones
Indie rom coms with real voices: ten small films from Rye Lane to Obvious Child, and why a smaller budget makes for a more specific love story.
On this shelf
Rye Lane 2023
2023
Two people, one day, and colour used like a punchline.
Best for A Saturday afternoon when you want something that feels new
The Half of It 2020
2020
A small-town teenager writes love letters for someone else and finds her own story in them.
Best for A quiet night with something gentle
Obvious Child 2014
2014
A stand-up comic has the worst week of her life and keeps telling jokes through it.
Best for When you want a rom com with an edge
Drinking Buddies 2013
2013
Two coworkers, one brewery, and a film that will not tell you how it ends.
Best for When you want something that refuses to resolve
The One I Love 2014
2014
A two-hander with a premise that should not work, and a lead pair who make it work.
Best for When you want the strangest thing on the list
Appropriate Behavior 2014
2014
A break-up comedy set in Brooklyn, with a voice that is entirely its own.
Best for When you want a story about a bisexual lead, told plainly
Hello, My Name Is Doris 2015
2015
A lead performance that could have been a joke and is played as a person instead.
Best for When your mother is in the room
Band Aid 2017
2017
A couple who write songs about their fights, which is a better premise than most studio films get.
Best for A weeknight when you want something small and odd
Comet 2014
2014
A relationship told out of order, with a pair who talk the way people actually talk.
Best for When you want the sad one
Results 2015
2015
A trainer and a client and a man in between, told with more patience than the premise suggests.
Best for When you want a gym-and-feelings evening
What an indie rom com actually is
Indie is a budget category, not a quality label. A romantic comedy is indie when the money came from somewhere other than a studio, which in practice means three things: the film is shorter, the cast is smaller, and nobody was in the room telling the writer to make the lead more likeable.
That last part is the reason this shelf exists. Studio rom coms are designed to be broadly appealing, and broadly appealing is exactly what makes a lot of them forgettable. An indie rom com can be specific — a particular city, a particular job, a particular kind of person — and specificity is what makes a love story feel like it is about someone.
What changes when there are no studio notes
The obvious change is that the endings get less tidy. Obvious Child and Appropriate Behavior both refuse the resolution a studio would have insisted on, and both are better for it. Drinking Buddies goes further: it refuses to resolve at all, and still works as a love story.
The less obvious change is the comedy. Studio comedy is built to land in a room of two hundred people. Indie comedy is built to land in a room of four, which means the jokes can be quieter, stranger and more specific — and they often age better, because they were not written for a test screening.
Where to start
Start with Rye Lane and The Half of It. The first is the best-looking film on this page and the one most likely to make you recommend it to someone the next day. The second is the gentlest, and the one that works for the widest range of ages.
If you want the version with teeth, go to Obvious Child — a stand-up comedy about a bad week, with a lead who is allowed to be difficult. And if you want the one that is formally strange, The One I Love is a two-hander with a premise I will not spoil, and it is the most interesting thing on the list.
What this shelf is not
It is not a claim that independent films are better. Plenty of indie rom coms are unwatchable, and the ones on this page are the survivors. The point is narrower: if you have run out of studio films and you want something that does not feel like it was assembled by a committee, this is where to look.
For the wider version of the same idea, underrated rom coms covers studio films that were marketed badly, and niche rom coms on the homepage is the whole argument in one place. If you want the studio peak instead, 2000s rom coms is the shelf.
Frequently asked questions
What counts as an indie rom com?
A romantic comedy financed outside the studio system, which usually means a smaller cast, a shorter runtime and no one in the room asking for a more likeable lead. The results are less tidy and often more specific.
Which indie rom com should I start with?
Rye Lane is the easiest to recommend and the best-looking. Obvious Child is the one with teeth. The One I Love is the strangest, and the one to watch if you want the form pushed.
Where can I watch indie rom coms?
They are usually available to rent or stream, though they move between services more often than studio films. Check your own app before planning the evening.